Salvesen v Riddell and another, Lord Advocate intervening (Scotland) before Lord Hope, Deputy PresidentLord KerrLord WilsonLord ReedLord Toulson JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 24 April 2013 Heard on 12 and 13 March 2013 AppellantJames Mure QCKenny McBrearty(Instructed by Scottish Government Legal Directorate Litigation Division) Advocates to the CourtW James Wolffe QCAlasdair Burnet(Instructed by the Solicitor to the Faculty of…

Barts and the London NHS Trust v Verma before Lord Hope, Deputy PresidentLord WalkerLady HaleLord SumptionLord Carnwath JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 24 April 2013 Heard on 27 February 2013 AppellantKaron Monaghan QCEdward Kemp(Instructed by Darbys Solicitors LLP) RespondentDavid WelchStephen Page(Instructed by Alexander Chambers)    IntervenerFrederic Reynold QCNadia Motraghi(Instructed by Bevan Brittan LLP) LORD CARNWATH (with whom Lord Hope, Lord…

Jones (by Caldwell) v First Tier Tribunal and Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority before Lord Hope, Deputy President Lord Walker Lady Hale Lord Sumption Lord Carnwath JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 17 April 2013 Heard on 28 February 2013 AppellantJames Eadie QCBen Collins(Instructed by Treasury Solicitor)  RespondentRobert Glancy QCGeorgina Hirsch(Instructed by Pattinson Brewer) LORD HOPE Nor was it satisfied that…

Public Relations Consultants Association Limited v The Newspaper Licensing Agency Limited and others before Lord Neuberger, President Lord Kerr Lord Clarke Lord Sumption Lord Carnwath JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 17 April 2013 Heard on 11 and 12 February 2013 AppellantHenry Carr QCAndrew Lykiardopoulos(Instructed by Baker & McKenzie LLP) RespondentRobert Howe QCEdmund Cullen QC(Instructed by Berwin Leighton…

Hayes (FC) v Willoughby before Lord Neuberger, PresidentLord ManceLord WilsonLord SumptionLord Reed JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 20 March 2013 Heard on 17 January 2013 AppellantClive Wolman(Instructed by Michael John Willoughby) RespondentRobin Allen QCAkua Reindorf(Instructed by Ginn & Co) LORD SUMPTION (with whom Lord Neuberger and Lord Wilson agree) “(3) Subsection (1) … does not apply to a course…

Schütz (UK) Limited v Werit (UK) Limited before Lord Neuberger, PresidentLord WalkerLady HaleLord ManceLord Kerr JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 13 March 2013 Heard on 15 and 16 January 2013 AppellantSimon Thorley QCThomas Mitcheson(Instructed by Hogan Lovells International LLP) RespondentRichard Meade QCLindsay Lane(Instructed by SNR Denton UK LLP) LORD NEUBERGER (with whom Lord Walker, Lady Hale, Lord Mance and…

Schütz (UK) Limited No 2 v Werit (UK) Limited before Lord Neuberger, PresidentLord WalkerLady HaleLord ManceLord Kerr JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 13 March 2013 Heard on 15 and 16 January 2013 AppellantSimon Thorley QCThomas Mitcheson(Instructed by Hogan Lovells International LLP) RespondentRichard Meade QCLindsay Lane(Instructed by SNR Denton UK LLP) LORD NEUBERGER (with whom Lord Walker, Lady Hale, Lord…

Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs v Aimia Coalition Loyalty UK Limited (formerly known as Loyalty Management UK Limited) before Lord Hope, Deputy PresidentLord WalkerLord WilsonLord ReedLord Carnwath JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 13 March 2013 Heard on 24 and 25 October 2012 AppellantPhilippa Whipple QCSuzanne Lambert(Instructed by VAT & Duties Litigation Team, Solicitor’s Office, HM Revenue and Customs) RespondentDavid…

Daejan Investments Limited v Benson and others before Lord Neuberger, PresidentLord Hope, Deputy PresidentLord ClarkeLord WilsonLord Sumption JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 6 March 2013 Heard on 4 December 2012 AppellantNicholas Dowding QCStephen Jourdan QC(Instructed by GSC Solicitors LLP) RespondentPhilip Rainey QCJonathan Upton(Instructed by Excello Law Limited) RespondenJames Fieldsend(Instructed by Jaffe Porter Crossick LLP) LORD NEUBERGER (with whom Lord…

Joint Administrators of Heritable Bank plc v The Winding-Up Board of Landsbanki Islands hf (Scotland) before Lord Hope, Deputy PresidentLord WalkerLord KerrLord ReedLord Carnwath JUDGMENT GIVEN ON 27 February 2013 Heard on 4 and 5 February 2013 Appellant Respondent David Alexander QC Gabriel Moss QC Stephen RobinsPaul O’Brien Martin Pascoe QCSarah Wolffe QCGeorgina Peters  (Instructed by Morrison…