Tskj Nigeria Limited V. Otochem Nigeria Limited (2018)

LAWGLOBAL HUB Lead Judgment Report

IBRAHIM TANKO MUHAMMAD, J.S.C.

The respondent herein, was the plaintiff at the High Court of Rivers State (trial Court). It is an incorporated limited liability Company which carries on the business of marine construction and equipment leasing.

The appellant herein, was the defendant at the trial Court. It is a limited liability company. It was the case of the respondent at the trial Court that sometime in February, 1997; it entered into a contract with the appellant for the supply of a houseboat for the temporary use of its staff. It was allegedly agreed that the appellant would make an advance payment of N6,288,000.00 representing the rental value at the rate of N100,000 per day for two months as well as the cost of transporting the houseboat from Warri to Bonny. Certain modifications were also to be made to the boat before delivery. It was contended that the terms and conditions of the contract were spelt out in a Local Purchase Order (LPO) issued by the appellant to the respondent.

It was the respondent’s case before the trial Court that after the houseboat was delivered, the appellant requested

1

that it be upgraded to European executive standard. Pursuant to this request the respondent alleged that it carried out further modifications to the boat at a cost of N12m. Upon completion of the modifications however, the appellant refused and/or neglected to settle the respondent’s bill. The respondent contended that the houseboat remained in the appellant’s possession for a period of 148 days before it was forced to retake possession thereof.

The appellant on the other hand, denied the respondent’s claims and contended that it did not take delivery of the houseboat because the respondent failed to meet the delivery deadline and also because it did not meet the required standard.

The respondent consequently instituted an action before the High Court of Rivers State, Port Harcourt Division. In its writ of summons at pages 1 – 3 of the printed record it sought the following reliefs against the appellant:

“a) N14,800,000.00 (Fourteen Million, Eight Hundred Thousand Naira only) representing hire rentals for 148 days (26th March, 1997 – 20th August 1997 inclusive).

b) N12, 000,000.00 (Twelve Million Naira Only) special damages.

2

(c) N40, 000,000.00 (Forty Million Naira only) general damages.”

At the conclusion of the trial, the learned trial judge entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff/respondent herein as follows:

1. The… special damages for the sum of N12,000,000.00.
2. The sum of N6,288,000.00 which was the money the defendant ought to have paid in advance before or at the delivery of the boat.
3. Daily hire for 2 months and 28 days on invoice No. 0072 for the sum of N8, 800,000.00.”

On the whole, judgment was entered for the plaintiff for a total sum of N32,088,000.00. The plaintiff was also entitled to costs which was assessed and fixed at N3,000.00 (Three Thousand Naira).